4 peanut butter chocolate chip cookies.Cover Love: I don't love this cover, but I do like that the girl represents Whitley well. She has got a suspicious look in her eye that I think fits her well.Why I Wanted to Read This: While I enjoyed The DUFF, Shut Out by this same author was one of my favorite contemporary teen romances last year. While this synopsis didn't really appeal to me, I will read anything Kody writes! Read the rest of this review here.