4 soft oatmeal butterscotch cookies.Cover Love: I really like this cover, but it's not the one for the book I read. The other one was okay though. My only problem with the newer Sonnenblick covers is that the boys look older than they are in the book. Although this kid looks like he could be a 7th grader.Why I Wanted To Read This Book:I started reading After Ever After because I booktalk it in school a lot and I had never read it. I was a few pages in when I realized it was the sequel to this one, so I stopped that one and pick this one up! Read the rest of my review here on my blog.